Shop
Seasonal Selections
Caramels & Pecanurtles
Classic Favorites
Fruits & Nuts
Small Bites
Signature Assortments
Truffles
Gift Sets
About Us
Our Story
Product Availability
Local Deliveries
Frequently Asked Questions
Contact
Give us a call now: 216 932-3200
Shop
Seasonal Selections
Caramels & Pecanurtles
Classic Favorites
Fruits & Nuts
Small Bites
Signature Assortments
Truffles
Gift Sets
About Us
Our Story
Product Availability
Local Deliveries
Frequently Asked Questions
Contact
Search
Menu
Menu
0
Shopping Cart
Instagram
Facebook
Need Phone Help?
Ohio and Beyond
Standard UPS
Sort by
Default
Default
Custom
Name
Price
Date
Popularity (sales)
Average rating
Relevance
Random
Product ID
Display
-1 Products per page
-1 Products per page
-2 Products per page
-3 Products per page
36-Piece Holiday Assortment
$
39.95
4 Piece Candy Cane Truffle
$
8.95
4 Piece Deluxe Assortment Gift
$
6.95
–
$
59.95
9 Piece Deluxe Assortment Gift
$
12.95
Advent Calendar 2023
$
44.95
Almonds
$
18.45
–
$
36.95
Apple Cider Caramels
$
6.95
Assorted Caramels Gift Set
$
21.95
–
$
42.95
Assorted Fruits & Nuts
$
39.95
–
$
79.95
Assorted Jelly Beans
$
6.95
–
$
29.95
Assorted Nuts
$
34.95
–
$
69.95
Assorted Nuts & Chewies
$
35.95
–
$
72.95
Black Walnut Clusters
$
19.95
–
$
39.95
Bourbon Smoked Salt Caramels
$
6.95
Brazil Nuts
$
18.45
–
$
36.95
Break Up Chocolate
$
8.95
–
$
26.95
Buckeye & Pretzel Box
$
32.95
Butter Rum Caramels
$
16.95
–
$
33.95
Caramel Crunch Popcorn
$
5.95
Caramel Wrapped Pretzels
$
4.95
Caramels
$
16.95
–
$
33.95
Cashew Clusters
$
18.45
–
$
36.95
Cherry Cordials
$
18.45
–
$
36.95
Chocolate Bars (3 oz.)
$
5.95
–
$
44.95
Chocolate Covered Mini Pretzels
$
6.95
Chocolate Malted Milk Balls
$
9.95
Coffee Lover’s Gift Set
$
44.95
Dark Chocolate & Pistachio Topped Orange Slices
$
19.95
Dark Chocolate Cordials
$
8.95
Dark Chocolate Covered Orange Peel
$
18.45
–
$
38.95
Dark Chocolate Foiled Leaves
$
6.95
Dark Chocolate Hot Cocoa Mix
$
11.95
Dark Chocolate Non Pareils
$
9.95
Deluxe Assortment
$
17.95
–
$
114.95
English Walnut Clusters
$
18.45
–
$
36.95
Fruit Slices
$
2.95
General Assortment
$
14.95
–
$
32.95
Ginger
$
18.45
–
$
36.95
Graham Cracker Duo
$
2.95
Hand-Dipped Figs
$
18.45
–
$
36.95
Hazelnuts
$
19.95
–
$
39.95
Lemon Peel
$
18.45
–
$
36.95
Limoncello Marzipan
$
9.95
Milk Chocolate Foiled Leaves
$
6.95
Milk Chocolate Gold Coins
$
4.95
Mitchell’s Buckeye Gift Box
$
49.95
Mitchell’s Chocolate Foil Bells
$
9.95
Mitchell’s Foil Eggs
$
9.95
–
$
11.95
Mitchell’s Peppermint Bark
$
12.95
Nut Crunch Brittle
$
5.95
–
$
7.95
Pecan Caramel Popcorn
$
6.95
Pecans
$
18.45
–
$
36.95
Pimento Olive – Chocolate Covered Almonds
$
8.95
Pineapple
$
18.45
–
$
36.95
Salted Caramels
$
10.95
–
$
42.95
Semisweet Baking Chunks
$
9.95
–
$
27.95
Signature Apricot Gift Set
$
14.95
–
$
42.95
Signature Apricots & Orange Peel Gift Set
$
21.95
–
$
42.95
Sour Gummy Bears
$
3.95
Sparkling Wine Cordials
$
8.95
Speckled Egg Spring Malted Milk Balls
$
9.95
Sugar-Free Almonds
$
9.95
Assorted Truffle Gift Set
$
9.95
–
$
64.95
Dark Chocolate Coconut Bonbons
$
8.95
–
$
36.95
Holiday Seasonal Flavor Assortment
$
18.95
Mint Truffles
$
9.95
Mitchell’s Buckeyes
$
8.95
–
$
33.95
Pecanurtles
$
19.95
–
$
44.95
Almond Bark
$
18.95
Almond Butter Crunch Toffee
$
18.95
–
$
36.95
Hazelnut Truffles
$
29.95
–
$
59.95
Peanut Clusters
$
16.95
–
$
33.95
Signature Chocolate Truffles
$
9.95
–
$
42.95
Mocha Truffles (Dark Chocolate)
$
9.95
–
$
42.95
Raisin Clusters
$
16.95
–
$
33.95
Coconut Haystacks
$
16.95
–
$
33.95
Grand Marnier Truffles (Dark Chocolate)
$
9.95
–
$
42.95
Fondant Creams
$
16.95
–
$
33.95
Rum Truffles (Dark Chocolate)
$
9.95
–
$
42.95
Marzipan (Dark Chocolate)
$
18.45
–
$
36.95
Raspberry Champagne Truffles
$
9.95
–
$
42.95
Turkish Coffee Cardamom Truffles
$
9.95
–
$
42.95
Peppermint Patties (Dark Chocolate)
$
16.95
–
$
33.95
Honeycomb Chips
$
16.95
–
$
33.95
Nougats
$
16.95
–
$
33.95
Peanut Butter Krispies
$
16.95
–
$
33.95
Raspberry Jellies
$
16.95
–
$
33.95
Marshmallow Assortments
$
8.95
–
$
39.95
Chocolate Covered Sourdough Pretzels
$
19.95
eGift Card – Emailed Instantly
Scroll to top
